The Oldest Conspiracy Against Thought

From the priest to the politician, the formula hasn’t changed: obedience in exchange for salvation. This essay dismantles the alliance between faith and power — and calls for heresy as the last refuge of free thought.
“To think is to be free; to obey is to be ruled.”
The Gospel of Obedience
It was supposed to be over. The Enlightenment—our species’ long, hard jailbreak from superstition—was meant to banish the ghosts of kings and gods for good. But in the 21st century, the candles of reason flicker once again, threatened not by darkness but by the comfort of submission.
In America—the nation that threw off the crown and the cross—we are watching both return under new management. A would-be monarch of ignorance presides over a nation of believers who prefer faith to facts, loyalty to logic, obedience to truth. The more things change, the more they kneel.
Only those who wish to rule ever condemn the act of thinking.
Divinity as Management
The birth of religion was less a spiritual awakening than a stroke of political genius. Primitive humans, confronted with thunder and famine, invented gods not to explain the world, but to manage it. The storm became divine wrath, the drought divine punishment. And conveniently, the remedy for divine anger always involved payment—sacrifice, tribute, or servitude.
“Fear in, obedience out.”
The earliest civilizations ran on that formula. The priests’ role was clear: translate the tantrums of heaven into policy. When the Roman Empire fell, the Catholic Church picked up the franchise. It perfected the art of spiritual taxation: sin, confess, pay, repeat.
Forgiveness was for sale, redemption available on credit. The popes thundered about poverty from marble balconies and feasted under ceilings painted with gold leaf. The miracle of transubstantiation was not turning wine into blood—it was turning guilt into revenue.
The Inquisition merely formalized the arrangement. Believe, or burn.
The Tyranny of the Nursery
Religion’s most enduring achievement, however, was its infiltration of the family. What began as theology became psychology. Parents, themselves indoctrinated, learned to mimic the divine. “Do as I say,” became “or God will punish you.” Later, God was replaced by Santa Claus, the Tooth Fairy, or the vague threat of cosmic disapproval.
“Obedience training for the soul.”
To terrify a child into virtue is still considered good parenting in many households, though the method differs little from the priest’s sermon or the tyrant’s decree. The result is the same: generations conditioned to equate submission with morality and guilt with goodness.
The line between the pulpit and the playroom has always been thinner than we care to admit.
The Renaissance of Ignorance
We are now witnessing a grotesque revival of this ancient order. The current American moment—equal parts carnival and catechism—has resurrected the authoritarian impulse in both church and state. The self-styled “King of Ignorance,” draped in flag and grievance, rules by the same creed as any medieval despot: bow or be punished.
Loyalty has become the new sacrament; dissent, the new heresy. Evangelical leaders—once the moral critics of power—now serve as its high priests. The televangelist and the politician have merged into a single organism: half preacher, half salesman, wholly corrupt.
The evangelical right learned long ago the secret that built Rome: if you control the definition of sin, you control the state. Convince the masses that their salvation depends on obedience, and you can sell them anything—from indulgences to assault rifles.
“The cross and the crown have always shared the same throne.”
The Eternal Child
Religion remains humanity’s most successful infantilization—the promise that someone else will make sense of the world, deliver justice, and clean up after us in the afterlife. It spares the believer the burden of uncertainty and flatters the ego with the illusion of cosmic importance.
Politics, ever the opportunist, seized upon this weakness. The demagogue, like the priest, thrives on dependence. He offers the same narcotic comfort: obedience in exchange for belonging.
Popes, dictators, and presidents all share a single trait—they demand worship while living in defiance of their own creeds. The hypocrisy is not a glitch; it is the operating system. Authority requires exemption from morality, lest it be revealed as merely human.
The Sweetness of Chains
One might ask, in an age of science and reason, why so many continue to kneel. The answer is unflattering: freedom is exhausting. To think for oneself means living without guarantees. Certainty, even when false, is easier to bear than doubt.
Thus, we outsource our conscience to priests, our politics to demagogues, our ethics to ancient texts written by men who thought epilepsy was possession and women were property.
“The great seduction of tyranny is that it relieves you of the duty to think.”
Voltaire warned that “those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.” He was not exaggerating. The same faith that burned heretics now bans books. The same blind obedience that silenced Galileo now silences scientists. The same impulse that crowned popes now anoints presidents.
The Modern Pulpit
Today’s sanctuaries are digital. The cathedral has Wi-Fi. The sermon is streamed in high definition. The choir chants in hashtags. The faithful send tithes through mobile apps while denouncing “elites” who can spell.
The modern cleric wears makeup and a microphone; the modern prophet hosts a cable show. The medium changes, but the message is unchanged: Do not question, only believe.
The war on intellectualism is no longer confined to religion; it has metastasized into politics, media, and education. Expertise itself is now elitist. Reason, suspicious. Knowledge, subversive.
“Ignorance, once a handicap, has become a political platform.”
The Heresy of Thought
The Enlightenment was not an era—it was a declaration of independence from authority. To say “I do not know” was an act of moral courage. To say “I will find out” was the birth of science.
That spirit, that blasphemous spark, remains the most revolutionary force in human history. Every advance—scientific, social, or moral—was an act of disobedience against gods and kings. The abolitionist defied scripture; the suffragist defied the pulpit; the scientist defied the heavens. Progress has always been, and will always be, the child of heresy.
“Blasphemy is the price of freedom.”
And yet, the craving for obedience remains. Millions long for the comfort of chains, for the fantasy of being ruled by something greater—so long as it spares them the responsibility of thinking.
The Reckoning
History, if it teaches anything, warns us that those who speak in the name of God almost always mean to rule in His place. Whether it is a cleric, a monarch, or a president, the psychology is identical: contempt for the independent mind.
To think is to threaten them. To doubt is to betray them. To laugh at them is to destroy them.
Let the record show that civilization has advanced only in direct proportion to the number of heretics it has produced. Our species grows not by faith, but by defiance.
When Diderot proposed that humanity would not be free until “the last king was strangled with the entrails of the last priest,” he was speaking not of literal murder but of intellectual emancipation—the liberation of the mind from the oldest con game in history.
That war is not over. It may never be. But the choice before us remains the same as it ever was:
Think, or kneel.
Why It Matters
From pulpit to podium, the message of obedience has always been weaponized to suppress dissent. This essay exposes the psychological and political continuity between divine authority and modern authoritarianism — urging readers to reclaim independent thought as the highest form of rebellion.
Key Takeaways
- Theocratic control evolved seamlessly into political tyranny.
- Obedience remains the most effective tool of oppression.
- Religion’s emotional manipulation mirrors state propaganda.
- Modern “faith” systems exploit fear for loyalty and profit.
- True liberation requires heresy — thinking freely against authority.
Further Reading (Bookshop.org)
- God Is Not Great — Christopher Hitchens. A fearless indictment of organized religion and its moral contradictions. https://civilheresy.com/god is not great
- The Age of Reason — Thomas Paine. The Enlightenment’s rallying cry against superstition and authority. https://civilheresy.com/the age of reason
- The End of Faith — Sam Harris. A sharp exploration of how religious certainty fuels violence and ignorance. https://civilheresy.com/the end of faith
Freedom isn’t given — it’s claimed. Wear the rebellion. Explore Shop Civil Heresy for gear that speaks truth.
